I took the above photograph earlier this month while visiting the Underground City (Toronto's disappointingly named PATH network). It's a table at the Pigeon Cafe where I got some free wifi, some power, and a chance to do some writing.
Hey, do you remember the heyday of blogging? Do you remember blogging memes? Looking through my old pages of this online journal of mine, I came upon this post from January 10, 2008 (eighteen years ago!). I titled it Top Ten Signs You're Reading Something from James Bow.
At the time, I was responding to a meme post by R.J Anderson (who is now mostly on Instagram, here) talking about the tropes of her writing. I did the same. At the time, I'd published two books of my Unwritten Books trilogy, with a third one due to come out later that year. The Unwritten Girl, Fathom Five, and The Young City, were upper middle-grade, young YA urban fantasy novels. Since then, I have two YA science fiction novels, a new adult urban fantasy, and I've self-published another YA urban fantasy, and edited and released a science-fiction anthology (see them all here).
How has my writing changed in the eighteen years since that meme? After reading what I wrote, I thought it might be good to revisit my points and see. So, without further ado:
Top Ten Signs You're Reading Something by James Bow
- No Real Villains. While at the time I had created a fairly irredeemable villain in the form of Aldous Magnait (The Young City), I still preferred to keep my villains in shades of grey. The antagonists of The Unwritten Girl and Fathom Five both had strong and pretty reasonable motivations to act as they did, and they either resolved their differences with the hero, or accepted a tragic end.
This definitely holds true for The Night Girl, The Dream King's Daughter and The Sun Runners. Such antagonists are just more interesting, in my opinion, as they bathe the hero in their shades of grey. However, while Nathaniel Tal (Icarus Down) may have been motivated by guilt and shame, he's definitely darker than my other villains, and the main antagonists for The Cloud Riders has motivations which do not excuse the actions they take. I think what's changed is that the real world has shown me some proper villains closer to home, acting through malice or incompetence or both. I can't understand these people, but they've given me permission to add them to my stories, and they've given me a bit of a template to draw upon. - God Exists? Let's Check the Machine. This statement was inspired by Rebecca's second point in her post, which states, "God exists. Deal." I thought our attitudes are similar, and I still think that, in terms of morality and ethics, our attitudes are still similar, though I find myself less interested in the question of whether God exists. I hope he does, but I have my doubts. It doesn't change the necessity for me to act with empathy -- something some White Christian Nationalist Heretics is trying to rebrand as a sin.
But in terms of my characters? Rosemary was raised Presbyterian and still attends during Christmas and Easter. Peter shrugs his shoulders agnostically and tags along. But Perpetua is not a believer -- or so she tells herself. Only when she's experiencing a moment of terror does she pray "for the first time in seven years".
But in my novels set in the future, I think my characters retain some spirituality, particularly Simon as he follows his strong moral code towards revealing the truth and calling out genocide. And in the Silent Earth sequence, Earthlings and Martians refer to God (singular). while Venusians and Mercurians refer to gods (plural), though they mostly express such sentiments while swearing. As Terry Pratchett says, atheism is well and good but, when you smash your thumb with a ball-peen hammer, you really could use the ability to blaspheme. - Such a Romantic. I still find it hard not to include a love interest in my stories, and add a bit of romance. That sort of thing just captures my interest, even in Madeleine L'Engle's A Wrinkle in Time. I was inspired to write the Unwritten Books because I wanted to follow the entire Meg-Calvin style relationship between Peter and Rosemary without skipping the part where they officially admit their love for each other, as Madeleine did jumping from A Wind in the Door to A Swiftly Tilting Planet.
But I have tried to branch off from this. Frieda in The Sun Runners isn't interested in that sort of intimate relationship, and threatens a constitutional crisis at the thought of having to marry someone. Samantha in The Cloud Riders backs away from an intimate relationship in order to help a dear friend. Who knows what the future will bring? - Characters Blowing Through Teeth, Quirking up Mouths, (Putting) Hands through (Their) Hair: Teeth continue to embed themselves in walls when I strive to show a character's frustration, though I am trying to quell these writing tropes. Add to this the raising of the eyebrows, and other pointless steps that I find myself including mostly to provide beats within the dialogue to indicate how the conversation is landing. On my current draft of The Cloud Riders, I've found that I've managed to cut a few thousand words from the manuscript by clearing out these things, and I fully expect my editor to tell me to clear out more.
- Location? Following the YA urban fantasies set on the Bruce Peninsula and Toronto (albeit Toronto in 1884), I returned to Toronto and its PATH network and made the city almost its own character within The Night Girl. I then went to rural Saskatchewan for The Dream King's Daughter, and most of my tales within Tales from the Silence stayed on a rebuilding Earth. Some of it comes from the adage of "write what you know". Some of it comes from the desire to feature more Canadian settings in science fiction and fantasy.
But I've been to Jupiter. I've been to Mercury, Venus and Mars, and halfway across the galaxy to Icarus Down. Striking out to parts unknown, while trying to remain within the realism of science fiction (as compared to the magical realism of fantasy) has proven an exhilarating challenge.
One thing I haven't done, however (outside of my short stories), is set a science fiction story on relatively contemporary Earth. That might change if I finish The Curator of Forgotten Things, set in Halifax. - I'm Ready for my Close-Up: I continue to stick closely to the protagonists' point-of-view in my tales, as part of the "show, don't tell" adage that's been drilled into my head throughout my years as a writer. Back in 2008, I (mildly, I hope) critiqued author Jenny Nimmo and her book Milo's Wolves for witholding a critical piece of information from the reader that the protagonist received in order to keep a key element of the plot a mystery. I ended up doing exactly that in The Sun Runners. I guess there are times when you need to pull the camera back, though I didn't keep the readers in suspense for too long (I hope).
I'd written nothing but third-person close-POV back in 2008, but I branched off to first person past tense with Icarus Down, and I'm returning to that with The Cloud Riders. The challenge with those books is finding the voice for the narrator that is distinctive from my voice. - Style Isn't Everything: At the time, Rebecca called my writing style "lucid". Others have said I keep things tight (aside from the writing tropes I've described above). I do find that's achieved through multiple drafts, including drafts where I go in to cut as much frippery as I can. In my raw writing, I find I still add a lot of placeholder words in order to measure out my beats, or waffle on what I intend to say (using later drafts to try and hone in). This may be why my manuscripts take a while to get to the publication stage (Ten years for The Sun Runners!).
But Erin has said that when it comes to my third-person stories, my style is to try and get out of the way as much as possible. Keep descriptions brief and suggestive, stay close to a single character's point of view (including giving the reader a window on their thoughts), show rather than tell, and try to let the readers themselves cast judgement on the protagonist's actions and reasons for them.
This is not something I follow a manual on. I don't have a template to do this. It just feels right to write as though I'm a silent cameraperson perched on the protagonist's shoulder. I vanish even further when I give the protagonist the narration duties with my first-person stories. - And the Girl Shall Lead Them: Back in 2008, my scorecard for my five novels (three published, one finished, one in progress) was four female protagonist to one male (Peter in Fathom Five). To that, I added one more male protagonist (Simon in Icarus Down) and another four female (five if you count Eliza, the co-star of Icarus Down). I didn't have any idea why this should be back then, and I still don't. It just interests me more; I can't explain why.
- And a Cast of... Seven: In my early days of writing, especially my fan fiction, I tended to keep the number of supporting characters down because I didn't want too many complications to the plot. My cast included a protagonist (the Doctor, Rosemary, Perpetua), secondary protagonist/love interest (Peter, Fergus, Polk), primary antagonist (Marjorie, Magnait, the Dream King), protagonist support character #1 (Puck, Faith, Earthenhouse), protagonist support character 2 (Arial, Edmund, Howard), and a couple of incidental characters to help things along.
My cast of characters have now grown. I have double protagonists for Icarus Down and The Sun Runners, and I've been less afraid to spend time developing minor support characters.
Possibly one effect of this has been an increase in my word count, from an average of around 50,000 for The Unwritten Books to something closer to 100,000 for Icarus Down and those that followed. I'm currently working on trying to pull The Cloud Riders back from a word count of 120,000. - Your Vision is as Good as Mine: At the time, I commented that I refrained from describing my characters, especially my main characters in detail, and I sure as heck avoided planting a character in front of a mirror at the start of a story to get such a description. (I have, however, done this trick in both The Dream King's Daughter and The Cloud Riders, but later in the story as the characters use this to assess either what's wrong with them, or how they've changed. Like rules you're not supposed to break, you can use tropes you're supposed to avoid, if you use them judiciously and well).
I still find that if you get the character's voice right (as narrator within first person, or by dipping into their thoughts within third person) and provide a few small hints, your readers will fill in the gaps for you, and produce a picture that is more real to them than you could easily do on their own.
I think a lot has changed in the eighteen years since I wrote the earlier post. I think I've developed and gained a lot more confidence as a writer. However, just as adulthood is, in many ways, an illusion (I see the world with the same sense of wonder and terror at 53 as I did at 13), as a writer, I continue to make it up as I go along. That is kind of the definition of writing, is it not? Even if we plot everything out thoroughly, or sketch our characters in our journals, the first step is still stumbling on discoveries and figuring out how to use them. And somehow we make it all work.